Over 60% haircut in FTMF shut funds is ‘Black Swan’ event: CFMA


New Delhi, Jan 21 | Describing the over 60 per cent haircut in six shut debt funds of Franklin Templeton as a ‘Black Swan’ event for three crore unit-holders of the entire domestic mutual fund industry, the Chennai Financial Markets and Accountability (CFMA), an organisation fighting for the cause of investors, on Thursday said three lakh unit-holders of Franklin Templeton Mutual Fund (FTMF) are set to lose Rs 16,000 crore out of Rs 28,000 crore invested.

“The FTMF unit-holders are not only set to lose over 60 per cent of their investments, but this will set a bad precedent for other mutual funds to go for such shenanigans which can erode the assets under management of the mutual fund industry by Rs 15 lakh crore out of the total asset under management of Rs 30 lakh crore,” the CFMA said, adding that this ‘Black Swan’ event may culminate into an Indian subprime crisis, akin to the US subprime crisis of 2008, if it is not controlled.

It reiterated that the recovery would not fetch more than Rs 12,000 crore as against the total receivable of Rs 28,000 crore and that too over a period of five to seven years. “At that time, there will be no FTMF, its President Sanjay Sapre and MD and CIO, India Fixed Income, Santosh Kamath.”

Notably, FTMF has said a majority of the unit-holders in its six frozen fixed-income schemes have voted in favour of an orderly winding-down. “Out of the total number of unit-holders who cast their votes, over 96 per cent of them have voted in favour of the winding up of the six schemes,” Sapre said in a communication to the investors.

The CFMA pointed out that FTMF has been claiming that it has realised more than Rs 13,000 crore in its six shut schemes, while its lawyers made statements before the Supreme Court that around Rs 9,000 crore are available for distribution without explaining how and where the remaining Rs 4,000 crore has vanished.

FTMF, which has front-ended the lie of COVID-19 as an excuse to abruptly shut down the six schemes, failed to explain how the pandemic reason has not been the case with its other schemes or any other mutual fund.

“The real reason for the winding up and ultimate loss to unit-holders is dubious investment decisions made by FTMF and its fund managers in connivance with trustees, AMC, KMP of the company along with the soft glove facilitation by the market regulator SEBI. This could be the main reason for FTMF to not make public the forensic audit report, despite the Gujarat High Court order. What is more surprising is the fact that even the SEBI, which has its fiduciary duty to protect the investors’ interests, has also objected to providing forensic audit reports to the unit-holders before the e-voting of six debt schemes,” the CFMA stated.

“It is of serious concern that none of the authorities, including the SEBI, has questioned the lies spread by FTMF and its fraudulent activities for winding up of six debt schemes,” CFMA said, adding that on the contrary, the SEBI was putting a stamp of approval on these lies.

By the time, according to the investor group, the unit-holders of FTMF will realise the fraud played on them, there would be no legal recourse left for them. “The regulator will escape by blaming the trustees and the trustees will escape by blaming the unit holders citing their consent to vote for the winding up.”

As a torchbearer, the CFMA believed that this issue will find its place in history, when ‘Black Swan’ event may culminate into an Indian subprime crisis, similar to the US subprime crisis of 2008. “However, there will be no recovery, as the regulator and legal processes would have already put a stamp of approval and it will set a precedent for three crore unit-holders across the mutual fund industry in India.”

The CFMA alleged that the entire e-voting process for the six shut schemes was conducted in a non-transparent and unfair manner and without the full knowledge of the findings in the forensic audit report. “Hence, the decision of unit-holders is not an informed one.”

“The SEBI’s announcement of appointing an observer was made after the voting commenced. Further, information on how many out of the three lakh unit-holders voted in the e-voting process was not provided,” the CFMA observed.

Source: IANS

Sponsors Posts

From being a developer to a CEO in California, Manthan Dudeja's top tips to make money while you're still in college

From being a developer to a CEO in California, Manthan Dudeja's top tips to make money while you're still in college

Gone are the days when one had to finish school, college and subsequent years in getting trained to be able to sustain oneself with decent income. Today, what you earn eventually depends upon your skillset and how early you got started to build an expertise in your domain.

Manthan Dudeja, who currently lives in California and is still in his graduation years, understood the perks of starting early and is now a CEO who has worked across a plethora of jobs, from IoS programming to website development and blogging to trying his hand at Amazon Associates.

In conversation with this dynamic entrepreneur, let’s decode the various options for freshers to make a side income while they are still in school/college –

  • Content writer/Editor

Manthan explains how he started off by writing for blogs with whatever knowledge he had and with the help of internet, this could be by either writing for your own online blog, for instance Manthan was interested in Tech, so he was writing for his blog ‘TechCrack‘ or for someone else in the capacity of a content writer.

It’s not difficult to get started if you have the basic understanding to develop a ‘flow’ while writing a piece and the skill to write what suits your target audience.

  • Software developers/ Programmers/ Coders – Today, software/app developers are earning more than the average of $60 an hour by working remotely. There are a host of online paid/free platforms providing trainings to acquire such skills, Manthan has been an app/website developer for the longest time and by far, this skill has given him the best results for his work.
  • Digital Marketer/ E-Marketer-

Your journey to become a digital marketer starts the day you take the step of self-educating yourself and learning the tricks to attract potential customers either by way of Google, Facebook, or any other digital platform by a host of scalable ways on the internet, undoubtedly, digital marketing is the hottest online work from home concept of this decade.

Manthan is today a successful digital marketer who has equipped himself with the advanced knowledge of online ads on various mediums and has effectively used these skills to generate incredible revenue over time.

These are some of the best ways to get started, according to Manthan, all


Sponsors Posts

2 BHK Residential Apartment for Sale in Aadhya Hills Bhita Jabalpur

2 BHK Residential Apartment for Sale in Aadhya Hills Bhita Jabalpur
Aadhya Hills is one of the residential development. It offers spacious and skillfully designed apartments. The project is well equipped with all modern amenities to facilitate the needs of the residents.
  • Property type: Residential Apartment 
  • Offer type: For Sale 
  • City: Jabalpur 
  • Zip Code: 482001 
  • Locality: Bhita 
  • Landmark: Bhita 
  • RERA Registration Number: P-JBP-18-1599 

For more details please click here or visit bhaskarproperty.com


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here