NCLAT sets aside plea against CarVal’s resolution plan for Uttam Value Steel


New Delhi, Sep 10 | The National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) has given its go ahead for the resolution plan of New York-based CarVal Investors’ to acquire the debt-ridden Uttam Value Steels Ltd.

The appellate tribunal in a judgment on Wednesday set aside a plea challenging the order by National Company Law Tribunal’s (NCLT) Principle Bench approving the resolution plan.

The company has a total admitted debt of Rs 3,003 crore.

The appellate tribunal noted that the appellants are aggrieved with the allocation of a “tiny” amount of 0.18 per cent of the outstanding dues.

The collective admitted operational debt of the appellant was Rs 423.82 crore which was 80.88 per cent of the total operational debt of the corporate debtor total being Rs 524 crore. The appellant was also representative of the operational creditor in the meeting of CoC, being holder of more than 10 per cent of the total admitted debt of Rs 3,003 crore.

Five operational creditors moved the NCLAT post the NCLT’s approval to the plan alleging that the adjudicating authority has approved the resolution plan, where the appellant is getting hardly 0.18 per cent or 0.19 per cent of its claims. The appellant is logically upset that they are paid 0.19 per cent whereas the Financial Creditors (CoC decision takers) are getting 41.75 per cent of their claims.

The figure cited by the Operational Creditor, that the Financial Creditor have got Rs 1,035 crore from an admitted debt of Rs 2,479 crore (41.75 per cent)

The three-judge bench said that the issue of prior approval from the Competition Commission of India (CCI) under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 is incorrect and CCI approval is not a condition precedent for the approval of the resolution plan.

“The CCI approval has been procured on June 4, 2019 in compliance with the provisions of the Code. It is submitted that condition requiring CCI Approval is ‘directory’ and having obtained the same, the provisions Section 31(4) have been complied with,” the order said.

After several observations, the NCLAT bench said: “We find that there is no merit in this Appeal and the Appeal is hereby dismissed. Pending IA, if any, are disposed of in terms of above observations and directions. Interim orders, if any, stand vacated. There shall be no order as to costs”

Source: IANS

Sponsors Posts

From being a developer to a CEO in California, Manthan Dudeja's top tips to make money while you're still in college

From being a developer to a CEO in California, Manthan Dudeja's top tips to make money while you're still in college

Gone are the days when one had to finish school, college and subsequent years in getting trained to be able to sustain oneself with decent income. Today, what you earn eventually depends upon your skillset and how early you got started to build an expertise in your domain.

Manthan Dudeja, who currently lives in California and is still in his graduation years, understood the perks of starting early and is now a CEO who has worked across a plethora of jobs, from IoS programming to website development and blogging to trying his hand at Amazon Associates.

In conversation with this dynamic entrepreneur, let’s decode the various options for freshers to make a side income while they are still in school/college –

  • Content writer/Editor

Manthan explains how he started off by writing for blogs with whatever knowledge he had and with the help of internet, this could be by either writing for your own online blog, for instance Manthan was interested in Tech, so he was writing for his blog ‘TechCrack‘ or for someone else in the capacity of a content writer.

It’s not difficult to get started if you have the basic understanding to develop a ‘flow’ while writing a piece and the skill to write what suits your target audience.

  • Software developers/ Programmers/ Coders – Today, software/app developers are earning more than the average of $60 an hour by working remotely. There are a host of online paid/free platforms providing trainings to acquire such skills, Manthan has been an app/website developer for the longest time and by far, this skill has given him the best results for his work.
  • Digital Marketer/ E-Marketer-

Your journey to become a digital marketer starts the day you take the step of self-educating yourself and learning the tricks to attract potential customers either by way of Google, Facebook, or any other digital platform by a host of scalable ways on the internet, undoubtedly, digital marketing is the hottest online work from home concept of this decade.

Manthan is today a successful digital marketer who has equipped himself with the advanced knowledge of online ads on various mediums and has effectively used these skills to generate incredible revenue over time.

These are some of the best ways to get started, according to Manthan, all


Sponsors Posts

2 BHK Residential Apartment for Sale in Aadhya Hills Bhita Jabalpur

2 BHK Residential Apartment for Sale in Aadhya Hills Bhita Jabalpur
Aadhya Hills is one of the residential development. It offers spacious and skillfully designed apartments. The project is well equipped with all modern amenities to facilitate the needs of the residents.
  • Property type: Residential Apartment 
  • Offer type: For Sale 
  • City: Jabalpur 
  • Zip Code: 482001 
  • Locality: Bhita 
  • Landmark: Bhita 
  • RERA Registration Number: P-JBP-18-1599 

For more details please click here or visit


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here