Internet privacy issues echo in Kashmir hearing


New Delhi, Nov 27 | The issue connected with Internet privacy echoed in the Supreme Court on Wednesday, as it pondered over the matter that if the government were to read all messages exchanged through various modes of communication then there might not be any privacy.

A bench headed by N.V. Ramana was hearing the submissions of senior advocate Kapil Sibal, representing senior Congress leader Ghulam Nabi Azad, challenging the restrictions imposed on Internet in the Kashmir Valley, which has affected the livelihood of traders and common people.

The Centre has justified the restriction on the Internet citing social media platform being used to serve the interest of a section of people seeking to propagate anti-state sentiments.

Solicitor General Tushar Mehta on Tuesday said that terrorists use social media as a weapon.

The court asked Sibal: “You appear for WhatsApp in some cases, can government ban it in a particular area?

Sibal said that it is a constitutional question, and the messages are end to end encrypted.

“WhatsApp can’t see messages, one can only send messages to five at a time,” said Sibal.

The court then asked him about various groups on WhatsApp, and would it not end up being used as a platform to send out messages. The bench asked was Sibal saying there should not have been any restriction on Internet at all?

Sibal replied that it was “one to one communication, like a telephone”.

The court observed that one to one submission in Internet communication is not correct.

“If I have email id, then I can send to thousand,” said a judge on the bench. Mehta said it is one to thousand.

Sibal replied that the goverment can temporarily ban WhatsApp in a given situation, and we have said it should be done.

Justice Ramana then asked whether it could be done technically?

Sibal said China has already done it, and then mentioned about National Technical Research Organisation, a technical intelligence agency under the National Security Advisor in the Prime Minister’s Office.

Sibal said: “There are organisation in our country which can read what you do, for instance NTRO which has same mandate as IB.”

Justice Ramana said: “So are you saying there is no privacy?”

Sibal replied that there should not be in matters of national security, and insisted platforms like WhatsApp do not compromise privacy.

Earlier, during the hearing the Solicitor General told the apex court that the location of the user id can be camouflaged.

“It can be shown to be anywhere in the world, be it Malaysia or Tanzania.” Sibal said on terrorism we are on the side of the establishment, but it cannot be an argument to paralyze lives of seven million people in the region.

Sibal said technology has to be balanced out, and cited the example of nuclear energy, “this technology was used in Hiroshima, but we use for electricity”.

He contended that abnormal conditions have been induced through restrictions. Sibal said the submissions on Kashmir is not about the past instead it is about the future, and the state should not muzzle the voice of common people.

Sibal also highlighted instances of misuse of technology. “Morphed images of me and my wife with beef in hand being circulated for last 5 years….. but we cannot do anything about it. Question is can everything be banned because of that?” Said Sibal.

Source: IANS

Sponsors Posts

1BHK Flats in Jabalpur for sale at budget price ?

1BHK Flats in Jabalpur for sale at budget price ?

Approximate 200+ 1BHK apartments or flats in Jabalpur available for sale at budget price

As per available data with approximate 200+ 1BHK Residential Flats for Sale in Jabalpur at a very low price. This is the right time for small property buyer to grab new property in Jabalpur with multiple benefits.

At this time Builder and Developer in Jabalpur also target to the maximum sale before the end of year. Also banks are giving low rate loan for housing. The 1BHK Flats for sale at multiple prime residential location in Jabalpur are available.

1BHK apartment’s starting price in Jabalpur is 12.0 Lac*

Some of the Real Estate Developer in Jabalpur are offering 1BHK Flat at Just 12.0 Lac (Starting Price) with multiple benefits like lift, parking, 24×7 water, CCTV and many more.

You can find more details about these from a Jabalpur Real Estate Website.

Most preferred residential location in Jabalpur

The most preferred residential locations in Jabalpur are Civil Lines, Vijay Nagar, Kachnar City, Napier Town, Wright Town, Lekha Nagar, Sadar, Sneh Nagar, Hathital and many more. is the best property portal for Jabalpur Real Estate market

The Bhaskar Property ( have property’s photos, video, walkthrough, location map and property browser with information. Also they provide the direct contact details of property owner and agent to whom a property buyer can directly contact.

Don’t forget to visit now.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here